Here’s why you should stop digging wet soil

Growing vegetables and plants is one of the most rewarding things to do in life, and for many gardeners, there’s always more work to be done. It can be tempting to spend every day outside digging, but when the weather is not cooperating, it is better to take some time indoors and let things dry out again.

Can you dig in wet soil? It’s best to avoid digging in wet soil. Working wet soil will cause it to compact after it dries, which is detrimental to soil health. Compact soil doesn’t allow air and water to penetrate properly; increasing the chance of root diseases and waterlogging.

The answer to digging wet soil isn’t just black and white. There are lots of contributing factors and even exception to the rule. Let’s take a close look at the effects of digging wet soil.


Why You Shouldn’t Dig in Wet Soil

It’s best to avoid digging in wet soil to prevent serious long-term damages. Soil Structure is susceptible to damages regardless of what tool you are using, whether it’s a plow, garden shovel, or even walking on the soil. Working wet soil will cause it to compact after it dries, which is detrimental to soil health

Working wet soil compacts soil particles tightly, preventing water and air from penetrating its surface. Compacted soil makes it challenging for plant roots to move through the ground. Damages caused by digging wet soil only show after it dries completely. Damaged soil forms tight clumps that become rock-hard and almost impossible to break. The roots of your plants won’t be able to penetrate these clumps. Furthermore, waterlogging might also become an issue with compacted soil. Damages of working wet soil last a long time and can become perpetual.

Once compacted, the soil will take many years to rebuild a healthy soil structure. I recently wrote a thorough guide to creating the perfect soil. Nonetheless, it’s best to avoid damaging your soil in the first place by simply resisting the urge to work it while it’s wet.


The Role of Soil Type when Digging in Wet Dirt

Soil is made from three main components, which are clay, sand, and silt. The ideal soil (sometimes referred to as loam) has equal amounts of all three, making it a fertile soil that drains effectively and is easy to dig. Each type of soil has its advantages and disadvantages, and each type handles wet conditions differently.

Sandy soils have substantial particles with large gaps between them. These spaces allow water and nutrients to drain away freely, making sandy soils less fertile than heavier soils. Sandy soils dry very quickly as well, so if there is rainfall, you will have to wait less long to dig than with other soil types.

Clay and silt soils are much heavier and have smaller particles. This means that water is less likely to drain away quickly, and the soil will become saturated for longer. These heavier soils are very fertile but are especially susceptible to being compacted. If you think of working in heavier soil after rain, be sure to postpone your digging a few more days to allow time for the earth to drain appropriately.


How Long Do You Have To Wait After Rain To Start Digging?

Understanding how long to wait before digging after rainfall depends heavily on the type of soil in your garden and the climate in which you live. If you have sandy soil, you may only need to wait a day or two before the ground is dry enough to work in. If you have heavy soils made of clay or silt, you may need to wait several days, sometimes weeks, before digging.

Your climate will also dictate how long you need to wait as much as the type of soil you have. For many sub-tropical southern regions in North America, the earth dries faster than in wetter places like the Pacific Northwest or the United Kingdom. Paying close attention to the weather and avoiding digging in your garden during these damp periods will ensure your plants have the best growing conditions.


How to Identify Perfect Digging Conditions

As with most gardening aspects, scientific methods can be used to grow vegetables effectively, but many horticulturalists agree that the cheapest and most effective strategy involves getting your hands dirty. To determine whether your garden’s soil is dry enough to work, try using the Ball Test.

Get a handful of soil and form a ball with your hands. Flick the ball; it either crumbles apart, indicating that the soil can be worked. Or it stays intact with a small dent. In this case, give the ground another few days to dry, and try again later.

As the weather dries and the earth of your garden does as well, regularly checking the soil will keep you informed. If you form a ball and it is not muddy, you are well on your way, but if a stream or even a few drops of water come out, it is still too wet to work with.


The Exception to the Rule: Perfect Soil

The easiest way to get around these difficulties is by having perfect soil. Most gardeners consider ideal soil to be a mixture of 40% sand, 40% silt, and 20% clay, referred to as loam. Loam has the best features of each of the three soil types by having the moisture and nutrient retention qualities of clay and silt, combined with sandy soil’s good drainage and airflow.

This perfect soil is not something that most gardens will start with. It is the result of understanding the soil you have and developing it into loam with various additions. The first thing that you should do is learn all about your soil’s level of life and what its texture is like. One way to determine your soil texture is by taking a sample of your earth to your local garden center as they should be able to identify it for you, or you can do a test at home.


How to Get Perfect Loamy Soil

Regardless of the kind of soil you have, adding organic matter to your garden will improve it. Whether your soil is heavy in clay, sandy, low in nutrients, compacted, or has poor drainage, organic matter will improve it. The best option right away is compost; it will enhance your soil immediately and introduce microorganisms that will continue improving the earth by further breaking down organic matter.

The old-fashioned method of incorporating compost is to dig it into the soil, but it is becoming increasingly recognized that no-till practices can benefit gardens enormously. Digging interrupts mycorrhizal fungi filaments that help plant roots grow downwards, giving plants access to nutrients deep in the earth.

Often you can spread the compost on top of the soil of your garden rather than dig it into it. Worms, rain, and microorganisms will mix it into the soil in a less disruptive manner. If you spread the compost in the fall, it will be thoroughly mixed into your garden by spring.

In addition to compost, you can add several other things to your soil to increase the amount of organic matter and its overall fertility. Grass clippings, shredded autumn leaves, aged manure, and coffee grounds will all improve the fertility, water retention, and overall texture of your soil.

These organic mulches insulate soil against temperature change, protecting it from high daytime temperatures and conserving heat by night. Any kind of organic mulch from newspaper to wood chips to leaves to compost has the advantage that as time passes, they decay, adding to the soil’s organic content.



Digging wet soil is undoubtedly damaging to your garden, but by understanding how the soil itself works, you can repair the damage done and avoid causing more in the future. Working toward perfect soil for your garden will benefit you in the long run and cause your vegetables and plants to flourish year after year.


Related Articles